Colonial Mediation in the Biographical Discourse of Kazakh Steppe Elites (mid-19th to early 20th Century)
Research Article
Keywords:
mediation, colonization, nobility, discourse, biographies, identity, intelligentsia, Empire, Asia, “foreigners”Abstract
The subject of the author's research is the representation in the discourse of biographies of Kazakh titled nobles of the Russian intelligentsia's ideas about the integration of the indigenous population of Central Asia into the system of social communication on the outskirts of the empire. The imperial power delegated to its experts – public figures, officials, scientists – the right of paternalistic tutelage over the new subjects to form a community of colonial mediators and to fulfil the tasks of empire-building in the situation of ethno-cultural diversity characteristic of the peripheral regions. The aim of the study is to reveal the content of the discourse of personal biographies of representatives of the Kazakh steppe aristocracy, constructed in the memoirs of imperial experts and recording the inclusion of these figures in the process of colonial mediation in the Central Asian regions in the second half of the 19th – early 20th centuries. A discourse on the biographies of Ch. Valikhanov, I.A. Altynsarin, and G.B. Valikhanov as presented in the memoirs of the Russian Federation. Valikhanov in the memoirs of Russian intellectuals, mastered by the methods of metacriticism and deconstruction of texts, made it possible to shift the research ‘optics’ from the trivial perception of the actors of the Kazakh social movement as foreigners in the service of the Russian Empire to the reception of their complex, often dual identity, which manifested itself on the one hand in the adoption of behavioural conventions of the Russian society, on the other – in the preservation and subsequent strengthening of ethno-cultural features of their own people. In the course of the study of the discourse of biographies, it was established that the phenomenon of colonial mediation was determined by the specifics of the integration of the titled nobility into the administrative, educational and social structures of Russia in the Central Asian region. This process was carried out in accordance with the Eurocentric ideas of the educated circles of the Russian Empire, which were moulded into an understanding of the Asian periphery as ‘Russia's own East’ and the indigenous population as ‘its own foreigners’ in relation to whom a model of intellectual and moral guardianship should be implemented. Cultural regeneration by means of Russian education and upbringing had an external effect and created a situation of quasi-comfort for the prominent leaders of the steppe aristocracy. As biographers themselves had to admit in their memoirs, within the line of personal and socio-political biography of prominent Kazakhs, there was a clear tendency to strengthen the national-cultural component of identity, which was expressed in the revision of attitudes and life values formed as a result of Russian influence.
Downloads
References
Absattarova Zh.B, Mazhitova Zh.S. Қazaқ ziialylary; әleumettіk-mәdeni sәikestіlіk; Dala өlkesі; bіlіm beru saiasaty; otarlau. Bulletin of L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University. Historical Sciences. Philosophy. Religious Studies. 2024. No.149(4), pp.177-193. (in Kazakh)
Abuev K.K. Sultan-Gazy Valikhanov. In: Steppe region of Eurasia: Historical and cultural interactions and modernity. Theses of reports and messages of the IV international scientific conference dedicated to the 170th anniversary of G.N. Potanin and Ch. Valikhanov. Pod red. A.P. Tolochko. Omsk: Omsk State University Publishing House. 2005. Рp. 139-144. (in Russian)
Aitmukhambetov A.A. Kazakhskie sluzhashchie Rossiiskoi imperii: formirovanie, professionalnaia i obshchestvenno-politicheskaia deiatelnost v XIX – nachale XX vv. (istoricheskii aspekt): Kazakh employees of the Russian Empire: formation, professional and socio-political activity in XIXth – early XXth centuries (historical aspect). Dissertation … Candidata of Historical Sciences". Semey, 2010. 346 p. (in Russian)
Asylbekov M.H., Seitov E.T. Alikhan Bukeikhan – obshchestvenno-politicheskii deiatel i uchenyi. Almaty. 2003. 148 p. (in Russian)
Bibliographic news. In: I. Altynsarin. Collected Works in 3 vol.1. Alma-Ata: Nauka Publ. 1975. Рp. 301-303. (in Russian)
Bykov P.V. G. Valikhanov. Biographical sketch. Niva. 1891. No.11, pp.258-259. (in Russian)
Veselovskaya N.I. Note. In: Works of Chokan Chingizovich Valikhanov. St. Petersburg: Tipography of the Main Department of Udeles. 1904. Рp. I-III. (in Russian)
Grigoriev V.V. Ob otnoshenii Rossii k Vostoku: Rech, proiznesennaia ispravliaiushchim dolzhnost professorom V. Grigorevym. Odessa. 1840. 18 p. (in Russian)
Jerasi R. Okno na Vostok: Imperiia, orientalizm, natsiia i religiia v Rossii. Moscow: New Literary Review. 2013. 548 p. (in Russian)
Dmitriev S.V. Chlen Russkogo geograficheskogo obshchestva general sultan Gazi Valikhanov. Countries and Peoples of the East. 2013. No.34, pp.311-323. (in Russian)
Yermekbay Zh.A. Russkii ofitser v Vostochnom Turkestane. Izvestia Irkutsk State University. Series: History. 2016. Vol.15, pp.137-145. (in Russian)
Ilminsky N.I. Vospominaniia ob I.A. Altynsarine. Kazan: Typo-lithography of V.M. Klyuchnikov. 1891. 396 p. (in Russian)
Ilminsky N.I. O perevode pravoslavnykh khristianskikh knig na inorodcheskie iazyki: Prakticheskie zamechaniia N. Ilminskogo. Kazan: University Printing House. 1875. 47 p. (in Russian)
Kappeler A. Rossiia – mnogonatsionalnaia imperiia. Vozniknovenie. Istoriia. Raspad. Moscow: Tradition: Progress-Tradition. 2000. 344 p. (in Russian)
Katkov M.N. Ideology of ochranitelstvo. Moscow: Institute of Russian Civilisation. 2009. 800 p. (in Russian)
Mazhitova Zh.S. Institut biev: podkhody i interpretatsii v rossiiskoi i kazakhstanskoi istoriografii. Monograph. Moscow: "KDU", "University book". 2015. 352 p.
Nurkina J.B., Churkin M.K., Amanzholuly A.E., Utegenov M.Z. Lichnaia i politicheskaia biografiia G. Valikhanova v imperskom kontekste rossiiskoi kolonizatsii KhIKh - nachala KhKh vv. Bylye Gody. 2023. No.18(1), pp.230-238. (in Russian)
Pavlova T.A. Psikhologicheskoe i sotsialnoe v istoricheskoi biografii. In: Political history on the threshold of the XXIth century: Traditions and innovations. Мoscow. 1995. Рp. 86-92. (in Russian)
Pismo N.I. Ilminskogo upravliaiushchemu kantseliariei sinoda V.K. Sableru ob I. Altynsarine In: I. Altynsarin. Collected Works in 3 vol. 1. Alma-Ata: Izdvo "Nauka" of the Kazakh SSR. 1975. Рp. 298-300. (in Russian)
Potanin G.N. Biograficheskie svedeniia o Ch. Valikhanove. In: Works by Chokan Chingizovich Valikhanov. St. Petersburg: Tipography of the Main Department of Udeles. 1904. pp. IV-XXXIV. (in Russian)
Potanin G.N. Nashi mechty. In: Ch.Ch. Valikhanov. Collected Works in 5 vol. Vol. IV. Alma-Ata: "Nauka" Publ. of the Kazakh SSR. 1968. Рp. 542-549. (in Russian)
Prazdnovanie v Peterburge i Moskve dnia 26 oktiabria 1581 goda. St. Petersburg: Tip. F. Eleonsky. 1882. 118 p. (in Russian)
Remnev A.V., Suvorova N.G. Kolonizatsiia Aziatskoi Rossii: imperskie i natsionalnye stsenarii vtoroi poloviny XIX – nachala XX veka: monograph. Omsk: Publishing House "Nauka". 2013. 248 p. (in Russian)
Repina L. P. Lichnost i obshchestvo, ili Istoriia v biografiiakh (vmesto predisloviia) In: History through personality. Historical biography today. Institute of General History of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Society of Intellectual History; edited by L. P. Repina. 2nd edition. Moscow: Quadriga Publishing House. 2010. Рp. 5-16. (in Russian)
Rusakova O.F. Metodologicheskie strategii v sovremennykh istoricheskikh issledovaniiakh: shkola «Annalov» i «Novaia intellektualnaia istoriia In: Scientific Yearbook of the Institute of Philosophy and Law of the Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences. 2001. Vol.2, pp.17-48. (in Russian)
Sartori P. Shablay P. Eksperimenty imperii. Adat, shariat i proizvodstvo znanii v Kazakhskoi stepi. Moscow: New Literary Review. 2019. 280 p. (in Russian)
Satenova M.R. Gazi Valikhanov i ego politicheskie vzgliady. Otan tarikhy. 2013. No.2 (62), pp. 65-71. (in Russian)
Toltz V. Sobstvennyi vostok Rossii»: Politika identichnosti i vostokovedenie v pozdneimperskii period. Мoscow: New Literary Review. 2013. 336 p. (in Russian)
Khodarkovsky M. Stepnye rubezhi Rossii: kak sozdavalas kolonialnaia imperiia 1500s-1800s. Moscow: New Literary Review. 2019. 352 p. (in Russian)
Churkin M. K. Reprezentatsii antikolonialnykh idei kazakhskoi intelligentsii Stepnogo kraia v obshchestvenno-politicheskom diskurse vtoroi poloviny KhIKh - nachala KhKh v. Vestnik of Omsk University. Series: Historical Sciences. 2020. Vol.7, no. 3 (27), pp. 22-28. (in Russian)
Churkin M.K. Model dialoga vlasti i obshchestva v travelogakh rossiiskikh puteshestvennikov KhIKh v. v Tsentralnuiu Aziiu. Ural Historical Bulletin. 2023. No.4 (81), pp. 16-23. (in Russian)
Epizod iz prosvetitelskoi deiatelnosti N.I. Ilminskogo. Pravoslavnyi blagovestnik. 1894. No.1, pp.26-31. (in Russian)
Yadrintsev N.M. Biograficheskie svedeniia o Ch. Valikhanove. In: Works of Chokan Chingizovich Valikhanov. St. Petersburg: Tipography of the Main Department of Udeles. 1904. pp. XXXV-XXXIX. (in Russian)
Yadrintsev N.M. Sibirskie inorodtsy, ikh byt i sovremennoe polozhenie. Tyumen: Yu. Mandrika Publishing House. 2000. 336 p. (in Russian)

Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Zh. Absattarova, Zh. Mazhitova, J. Omurova

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.